Guide · Prediction markets
Prediction market arbitrage: why the displayed profit disappears
Why a Kalshi or Polymarket arbitrage that looks like profit often isn't: asks vs displayed prices, each venue's fee formula, book depth and settlement rules.
Updated Nov 10, 2026Facts checked Nov 10, 2026
On this page
- Key takeaways
- Why prediction market arbitrage looks profitable
- Reason 1: the scanner's price isn't the price you pay
- Reason 2: fees, and how each venue charges them
- Reason 3: there isn't enough at that price
- Reason 4: the two markets don't settle the same way
- Reason 5: your money is locked until settlement
- How to check an opportunity before you trade
- Bottom line
- Frequently asked questions
Prediction market arbitrage means buying YES on an outcome at one venue and NO at another, such as Kalshi and Polymarket, when the two prices add up to less than $1. The displayed gap often disappears because scanners show last or mid prices instead of the ask, and because both venues charge fees that peak near 50 cents.
This guide uses each venue's own fee schedule, read on Nov. 10, 2026,[1][2][3] and Reddit threads where traders describe what happened when they tried it. Fees change often; check the schedule before you trade. Work through your own numbers with our prediction market arbitrage calculator.
Key takeaways
- The gap you see isn't the gap you get. Use the ask on both sides, not the last trade or the midpoint.
- Fees are per contract and largest near 50 cents. On a typical cross-venue pair they can eat 4 cents of a dollar.
- Depth matters. A 3-cent gap on 20 contracts isn't a 3-cent gap on 500.
- Settlement rules must match exactly, or both legs can lose.
Why prediction market arbitrage looks profitable
Every binary contract pays $1 if its outcome happens. Buy YES on venue A for 45 cents and NO on venue B for 52 cents, and you've paid 97 cents for a guaranteed $1: a 3-cent gross profit per pair, 3.1% on the money you put in. That's the arithmetic every arbitrage scanner shows.
Traders report that it rarely survives. In October 2026, a beginner on r/arbitragebetting said their Kalshi and Polymarket payouts didn't match what their software indicated; replies pointed to displayed versus executable prices and fees.[5] Another trader who compared prices on 129 Premier League and Champions League matches over about 70 days reported a median difference of zero and no pre-match gap large enough to clear fees, while noting that their data had minute-level prices rather than full order books.[6] Both are self-reported.
Reason 1: the scanner's price isn't the price you pay
A prediction market has an order book: a best bid (what buyers offer) and a best ask (what sellers want). A scanner that shows the last traded price or the midpoint can make a gap look bigger than it is. If the last trades were 43 and 50 cents but the asks are 45 and 52, a 7-cent gap is really 3 cents. Always compare asks, since you're the one buying.
Reason 2: fees, and how each venue charges them
All three schedules use the same shape: a coefficient × contracts × price × (1 − price). That makes fees largest at 50 cents and smallest near 1 or 99 cents.
| Venue | Taker fee (sports) | Maker fee | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Kalshi | 0.07 × C × P × (1 − P), rounded up | 0.0175 × C × P × (1 − P) (most sports series carry a maker multiplier of 1) | Kalshi fee schedule, effective July 7, 2026[1] |
| Polymarket US | Θ × C × P × (1 − P); Θ is 0.095 below $10,000 of 30-day taker volume, down to 0.0695 at $250,000+ | Rebate at higher volume tiers | Polymarket US schedule, effective Oct. 28, 2026[2] |
| Polymarket (international) | 0.05 × C × P × (1 − P) | None; 15% of sports taker fees rebated to makers | Polymarket docs[3] |
Kalshi charges no settlement fee.[1] Polymarket's international platform lists the US as a close-only jurisdiction, where users can't open new positions;[4] US traders use Polymarket US.
Worked example
100 contracts each side: YES on Kalshi at a 45-cent ask, NO on Polymarket US at a 52-cent ask, both as taker orders.
| Amount | |
|---|---|
| Cost of both legs | $97.00 |
| Payout at settlement | $100.00 |
| Gross profit | $3.00 |
| Kalshi fee: 0.07 × 100 × 0.45 × 0.55 | $1.73 |
| Polymarket US fee (Tier 1): 0.095 × 100 × 0.52 × 0.48 | $2.37 |
| Net profit | −$1.10 |
The same pair with the NO leg on Polymarket's international platform (0.05 coefficient, fee $1.25) nets about $0.02. At prices near 50 cents, a new trader on Kalshi and Polymarket US needs a gap of roughly 4 cents just to break even. Making instead of taking cuts fees, but a resting order may not fill before the gap closes.
Reason 3: there isn't enough at that price
The best ask may only have a few dozen contracts behind it. Fill more and you walk up the book to worse prices. A September 2026 thread about an arbitrage bot described finding smaller post-fee opportunities than promotional examples suggested, and limited liquidity behind them.[8] Check depth on both legs before sizing, and remember that if one leg fills and the other doesn't, you're holding a one-sided position.
Reason 4: the two markets don't settle the same way
"Will Team A win?" can mean regulation time on one venue and including overtime on another, or use different data sources and cut-off times. If the venues resolve the same event differently, both legs can lose. The arbitrage-bot thread flagged matching resolution rules as essential.[8] Read both markets' rules before trading, every time.
Reason 5: your money is locked until settlement
A 3.1% gross return sounds small; over a 30-day hold it's about 38% a year simple, or 45% compounded, which is why it attracts attention. But the capital can't be reused until the market settles, and a user who simulated a $1,000 bankroll from late September described capital lockup as a main constraint.[7] Long-dated markets tie money up for months for a few cents.
How to check an opportunity before you trade
- Use the ask on both legs, at the size you want to trade.
- Apply each venue's current fee formula at those prices.
- Confirm the resolution rules match word for word.
- Count the days to settlement and compare the net return with doing nothing.
Our prediction market arbitrage calculator does steps 1, 2 and 4.
Bottom line
Prediction market arbitrage is real arithmetic, but most displayed gaps between Kalshi and Polymarket are smaller than the fees on both legs once you price them at the ask. Treat any gap under about 4 cents near 50-cent prices as likely negative, check depth and settlement rules, and count the time your money is locked up.
Call or text 1-800-MY-RESET (1-800-697-3738). You can also text 1-800-522-4700 or chat at 1800myreset.org.Frequently asked questions
What is prediction market arbitrage?
Buying YES on an outcome at one venue and NO on the same outcome at another, such as Kalshi and Polymarket, when the two prices add up to less than $1. One side pays $1 at settlement, so the gap is the gross profit before fees.
Why doesn't my prediction market arbitrage pay what the scanner showed?
Usually one of four things: the scanner showed a last or mid price rather than the ask you actually pay; trading fees, which on Kalshi and Polymarket are charged per contract and are largest near 50 cents; there weren't enough contracts at that price; or the two markets settle on slightly different rules.
How much are Kalshi's fees?
Kalshi's taker fee is 0.07 × contracts × price × (1 − price), rounded up, so 100 contracts at 45 cents costs about $1.73. Many sports markets use that standard rate. There's no settlement fee.
How much are Polymarket's fees?
Polymarket US charges takers Θ × contracts × price × (1 − price), with Θ from 0.095 for accounts under $10,000 of monthly taker volume down to 0.0695. Polymarket's international platform charges sports takers 0.05 × contracts × price × (1 − price), and makers pay nothing.
Is cross-platform arbitrage risk-free?
No. Fees can turn a small gap negative, the second leg's price can move before you fill it, and if the two venues resolve the event differently you can lose both sides. Your money is also locked up until settlement.
Sources
- 1.Kalshi Fee Schedule, KalshiOfficial vendor documentation · accessed Nov 10, 2026
- 2.Polymarket US Trading Fee Schedule, Polymarket USOfficial vendor documentation · accessed Nov 10, 2026
- 3.Fees (Polymarket documentation), PolymarketOfficial vendor documentation · accessed Nov 10, 2026
- 4.Geographic Restrictions (Polymarket documentation), PolymarketOfficial vendor documentation · accessed Nov 11, 2026
- 5.New (r/arbitragebetting, Oct. 24, 2026), RedditUser report · accessed Nov 10, 2026
- 6.I compared Kalshi and Polymarket prices on 129 matches (r/Kalshi, Oct. 19, 2026), RedditUser report · accessed Nov 10, 2026
- 7.How guaranteed arbitrage on Kalshi/Polymarket actually works (r/predictionsandbetting, Oct. 24, 2026), RedditUser report · accessed Nov 10, 2026
- 8.I made a bot that spots risk-free arbitrage (r/algotrading, Sept. 29, 2026), RedditUser report · accessed Nov 10, 2026
About this page
- Editorial checks
- Checked against the sources cited on this page. We correct it when a source changes or a reader reports an error.
- Facts last checked
- Nov 10, 2026
How we research and label evidence: our methodology.
Keep reading
ToolPrediction markets
Prediction market arbitrage calculator: profit after fees
Free Kalshi and Polymarket arbitrage calculator: enter both asks and contract counts to see each venue's fee, net profit and annualized return.
Updated Nov 10, 2026
GuideArbitrage betting
Arbitrage betting explained: how it works, with examples
How arbitrage betting works, how to size each stake, a worked example, and the practical risks that turn a calculated arb into a loss.
Updated Nov 18, 2026
ToolArbitrage betting
Arbitrage calculator
Work out how to split your stake across two or three outcomes, see the modeled return, and check how rounding changes each outcome's profit.
Updated Oct 28, 2026
GuidePrediction markets
Kalshi fees: how much Kalshi charges per contract, explained
How Kalshi's trading fee works: the per-contract formula, maker vs taker fees, fees at every price, how it compares with sportsbook vig, and deposit fees.
Updated Nov 12, 2026